Taylor Swift's “TNT” bracelet by Travis Kelce was seen at a wedding in NYC

The romance between Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce began with a friendship bracelet – and now another bracelet remains part of their love story.

After attending the New York City wedding of model Karen Elson and Electric Lady Studios owner Lee Foster on Saturday, September 7, the “So High School” singer, 34, showed off a special piece of jewelry from Kelce.

On Swift's left wrist, she wore her “TNT” friendship bracelet, which the 34-year-old Super Bowl champion had made especially for her. Kelce also has a matching bracelet.

The elegant bracelet was clearly visible as the NFL star walked Swift by the hand along the sidewalk to her car at the end of the evening.

For the wedding, Swift wore a cream-colored Halliday Scallop midi dress by Zimmermann with a corset pattern on the back and cut-outs.

Kelce opted for an all-black outfit with slicked-back hair. He accessorized with a gold watch to complete the Saturday night look.

The jewelry was made by Wove Made Inc. Jewelers, who previously told PEOPLE they were thrilled that Kelce contacted them about the design.

The bracelet is made of 14k yellow gold and 4.62 carats of lab-grown diamonds. “TNT,” presumably for her initials, adds a sentimental touch.

The bracelet was first spotted on Swift when she hugged Kelce after the Kansas City Chiefs won the AFC Championship game on January 28.

“We had almost given up hope of ever seeing her with the bracelet until THAT infamous hug,” Simone Kendle, CEO of Wove Made Inc., previously told PEOPLE. “As she wrapped her arms around Travis to congratulate him, a member of our team saw the bracelet peeking out from under her sweater and raised the alarm!”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE's free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

In July 2023, Kelce attended Swift's Eras Tour show in Kansas City and tried to give her a friendship bracelet with his phone number on it. Weeks after the show, the tight end told his brother Jason Kelce during their podcast New heights about his failed attempt.

“I was disappointed that she doesn't speak before or after her performances because she has to conserve her voice for the 44 songs she sings. So I was a little pissed that I couldn't give her one of the bracelets I made for her,” Travis said at the time. “She's not meeting anyone, or at least she didn't want to meet me, so I took it personally.”